The world's best athletes have coaches. Most have several, each one helping them sharpen a different skill so they can compete at their best.
The same is true in real estate investing, and in almost every part of life. We all need guidance, and having a real estate mentor is one of the best things you can do for your business. There is a right way and a wrong way to find one, so this Simple Guide walks through how to find and approach a mentor.
Why do you need a mentor?
To be honest, I don't know many successful investors who got there without a mentor. Think about the advantage of having a seasoned investor to bounce ideas off of, someone who can help you avoid costly mistakes early on.
Plans fail for lack of counsel, but with many advisers they succeed. Proverbs 15:22
A mentor keeps you on track and holds you accountable. You need someone pushing you, someone you trust and someone you don't want to let down.
When I look back at my life, I had many mentors, and I didn't realize some of them were mentors at the time. Some taught me the right way to do things. From others, I learned how not to do things.
My dad introduced me to a man who owned a timber company. He bought large tracts of land across Indiana, harvested the timber, then sold the land. He followed that simple system over and over and built real wealth doing it.
I didn't know how to cut down trees or run the machinery, but I knew I could help him find land. For about a year and a half I worked as an independent contractor, earning a commission on the deals I brought in. I spent hours driving across Indiana looking for land and calling owners to ask if they wanted to sell.
He was in his sixties, didn't use email, rarely answered his phone and wasn't much of a speaker. I couldn't figure out how he had done so well. But on our drives he would share little nuggets, and one of the greatest lessons he taught me was that bigger isn't always better. He had once grown to 15 employees with huge overhead and nearly lost everything.
That lesson stuck. When I got into real estate and started making money, I was pulled in every direction: buying, rehabbing, flipping, just too much of everything. I wasn't happy. I was trying to go too big. I needed to simplify, and I decided I was going to keep things simple in how I ran my business. That idea of keeping things simple still shapes how we run our business today.
Once my business got rolling and I felt like I was doing well, I stopped doing the things that had helped me most. I stopped asking questions. I stopped seeking help. I stopped reading. And when I thought I knew it all, I lost my drive. One of the greatest things a mentor can give you is the drive to keep getting better.
Why do you need a mentor? To help get you from where you are to where you want to be.
Now I am constantly seeking advice from people who are doing what I want to do. I read and listen to books from entrepreneurs, investors and Christian leaders any chance I get. When do I feel closest to the Lord? When I am deliberately seeking Him. Business is the same. I can't sit back and wait for ideas or deals to come to me.
Two of the best things that happened for my business came through mentorship: I hired a business coach, and I joined a mastermind group of real estate investors.
My personal story: learning what not to do
When I first started investing, I bought my very first property on eBay for $10,000 and sold it for $15,000. I had sold all kinds of things on eBay, so I started looking for more deals and other investors there.
That led me to a man I'll call Jeremy. His family had given him a large sum of money to start a business, and he was buying cheap houses across Indiana, Michigan and Ohio to resell on eBay. He needed someone to sell them online. I had already sold all kinds of crazy things on eBay, from cars to bootleg movies, so I offered to do it for a commission.
He was buying hundreds of properties he had never seen, and many were in terrible shape. Buyers were upset because the houses were misrepresented, and they came after me because I was the one posting them. He kept people quiet by paying them off. It was a mess. He wasn't running an ethical business, so I saved up and left to start my own.
Was he a mentor? Yes. I learned a lot from him, good and bad. Mentors teach you what to do, and they also teach you what not to do. My mistake was that I never asked him about his core values.
What to look for in a mentor
Before you look for a mentor, get clear on your own goals and values, so you and your mentor are on the same page about where you are headed. Ask yourself:
- What are my core values?
- What am I passionate about in life?
- What is one area I'm struggling with in my business?
- How could a mentor help me in that area?
Later you'll ask a potential mentor similar questions to make sure your values line up.
Next, look for someone who is actually doing the kind of investing you want to do. There are many strategies: fix and flip, wholetail, buy and hold rentals, owner financing, land, apartments and more. I strongly recommend picking one strategy and mastering it first.
At one point I was trying to do everything. I was buying, rehabbing and flipping, and I didn't really know what I was doing because I had no construction experience. Contractors took advantage of me, I was losing money and I was stressed out. My first mentor taught me that I don't have to do a lot of things. I just need to do one thing really well.
I get a lot of requests for mentorship. Often our values don't match, or the person wants to learn a strategy we don't practice, and honestly, I can't add much value in that case. So pick your strategy first, and find a mentor who specializes in it.
How to find a seasoned real estate investor
The best way to find seasoned investors is to go where they spend time.
- BiggerPockets. It's a great place to network. Set keyword alerts for your area, such as Indianapolis and Indianapolis investor, so you see who posts often.
- Your local Real Estate Investors Association (REIA). A lot of investors attend, and it's one of the best ways to meet people in your market.
- The MLS. If you're a licensed agent, you can search for cash buyers who have bought in your market in the last six months.
- Meetup.com and local investor groups, including our own Indy Investor MeetUp.
Don't ask to be mentored
We get requests every week from people asking us to mentor them. That isn't the best way to go about it.
When you meet someone you're interested in dating, you don't ask them to marry you on the first day. You get to know them first. Approaching a mentor works the same way.
It all boils down to relationship
Make sure the two of you fit well and that the relationship benefits you both. Invite a potential mentor to coffee or lunch and get to know them. In that first meeting, ask:
- What are your core values?
- What are you passionate about in life?
- What kind of investing do you do, and how do you do it?
- What would you suggest for someone just starting out?
- Do you ever partner on deals?
Discover their needs
Investors are busy people. Mentoring takes time away from their business, their team or their family. Give them a reason to invest in you.
Take the word mentor out of your vocabulary and ask one of these instead: How can I bring you value? Is there anything I can help you with?
That approach isn't self centered, and it is a great way to build a relationship with an experienced investor. Find ways to help. Offer to drive for dollars, take seller calls, help manage properties or look at land, whatever they need. Your message should be that you want to help and learn.
Create and add value
Look for chances to add value to their life and business. When I worked for the timber company, I couldn't run the machinery, but I knew every investor needs deals. So I added value by finding land, and those deals were a big help to him.
Jaren's story
Jaren, who used to co-host our podcast, is a great example. He had worked for BiggerPockets and was moving to Indianapolis from Oakland, California. He got his real estate license and started looking for someone ethical to work for.
He asked his network for introductions and was connected with Stephen Barton, who I was mentoring at the time. When Jaren and I finally sat down, the whole conversation was about how he could add value to our company.
We didn't need him as an agent then, but I knew nothing about social media, so I put him in charge of social media and content. He ran with it. He worked around the clock, produced content and wrote our very first ebook. I saw his hunger and the value he brought, and he worked his way up to a full time role. He went on to serve as our sales and marketing manager, our dispositions manager, our podcast co-host and a real estate broker.
I gave Jaren an inch and he ran a mile.
One last tip: if you want to get noticed by an investor, find a way to bring them a good deal. Nothing adds value faster.
The effects and results of having a mentor
When I first started, I had a mentor and my business took off. Then I thought I knew it all. For three or four years I stopped reading, stopped asking for advice and stopped learning. My business became stagnant, and I realized I had stunted my own growth.
In recent years I've hired a business coach, joined a mastermind group, read and listened to books nonstop and kept asking questions. My business has doubled because of mentorship.
Paying for mentors and coaches
I've had mentors who were free and some I paid. If you're considering paying, decide what you're willing to spend and look at it as an investment, not an expense. If you pay $1,000 and it helps you make $10,000, it was worth it. It depends on whether the mentor truly has what it takes to get you to the next level.
My mastermind group experience
A few years ago I was invited to join a mastermind group called the Collective Genius, which connects investors from across the country to share best practices each quarter. At the time it cost roughly $20,000 to $25,000 a year plus travel. It was a big commitment, and it has benefited our company tremendously. The connections alone were worth it, and they've brought great guests to our podcast.
Be very cautious
If you're just starting out, be careful about spending $20,000 on a mastermind built for investors doing many deals a month. Know where you are in your journey and choose mentors to match.
Have you ever sat through a timeshare presentation? They hype it up for two hours, bring in another speaker if that doesn't work, then tell you what you'll miss if you don't buy. Many paid mentorship programs work the same way. Free seminars lead into programs that cost $20,000 to $50,000, and some encourage people to put it on credit cards before they have even started. Mentorship should never be high pressure. If a potential mentor isn't actively doing deals, steer clear.
Think outside the box
You can also learn from people you'll never meet: subscribe to their YouTube channel, read their book or follow them on social media. Don't limit your options.
Follow through
If you want results, you have to take action. Don't pick a mentor's brain and disappear. Follow through, and a good mentor will want to invest more in you.
Conclusion
My business suffered when I stopped seeking wisdom, and I don't want that for yours. Even when things are going well, never stop learning. Read, listen to podcasts, find an accountability partner, join a mastermind and keep growing.
Want to meet other local investors? Join us at the next Indy Investor MeetUp.











